• Home
  • About Us
    • About the Publisher
    • Advertise with Us
  • Contact Us
  • Login
  • Subscribe

Grimag

  • Editor’s Notes
  • OSM! Video Gallery
  • Biting The Big Apple

Texas District Court’s DACA Ban: A Dire Need for Immigration Reforms

By Licelle Cobrador, Esq.

New York – Texas has been in the spotlight lately. Judge Andrew S. Hanen of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas held that Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals/DACA violates the substantive provisions of the Administrative Procedure Act/APA on July 16, 2021. The APA directs that federal agencies follow certain processes in implementing new regulatory policies. The court vacated the June 15, 2012 memorandum that created DACA.

In Judge Hanen’s 77-page decision, he called DACA an “illegally implemented program.” This was in response to a Texas-led, multi-state challenge to the legality of DACA in the case known as Texas v. United States. Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, who brought the lawsuit versus the Biden Administration argued, “DACA amounts to a constitutional violation because the Executive cannot exercise such legislative powers—it cannot dispense with statutes addressing unlawful presence by declaring a class of aliens to henceforth be present lawfully.” However, in response, the court declared, “To resolve the issues concerning the legality of DACA, the court need not address whether the Executive Branch has violated its duties under the Constitution.” Further, it took no position on how DHS (or Congress) should settle any of the considerations put forth.

The lingering question in people’s minds: What about the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2020 decision in Department of Homeland Security v. Regents of the University of California?

In that case, the U.S. Supreme Court held that the Trump administration’s move to terminate DACA was unlawful. Although it allowed DACA to endure, it did not directly address the specific issue the Texas district court tackled: Was the DACA program issued properly in its inception? Here, the Texas district court ruled in the negative. In short, the Supreme Court did not go into the merits of DACA in that case.

What are the implications of the Texas federal court’s decision?

Acknowledging the harmful impact of a permanent injunction if such was to go fully into effect straightaway, the court stayed its injunction with respect to those with DACA status on July 16, 2021, and for individuals filing renewal applications, which include requests from current DACA holders and requests from individuals whose DACA grant expired less than a year earlier.  Therefore, the USCIS may continue processing renewal applications, including applications to renew DACA work permits. However, the USCIS cannot process initial DACA applications and those previously granted DACA, but failed to request renewal within one year of expiration. The Service also stated that employers should not use the recent court decision to make any employee show more or different documentation to verify their employment authorization. Employers should continue to recognize that DACA work permits are satisfactory to establish work authorization. Furthermore, neither this order nor the accompanying injunction mandates DHS or the Department of Justice to take any immigration, deportation or criminal action against any DACA grantee, applicant or any other individual that it would not otherwise take.

What’s next?

The Texas federal court’s ruling illuminates the stark reality that the U.S. needs comprehensive immigration reform. President Joseph Biden proclaimed, “the federal court ruling is deeply disappointing.” Senate Majority Leader Charles Schumer (D-NY) and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) vowed to press forward on legislation that would ensure the dreamers have a pathway to citizenship. Congress can ensure a permanent solution for the DACA population who are generally well-educated and positive contributors to the betterment of this country. #

DISCLAIMER

This column serves primarily as a guide. It aims to provide general information on immigration law. The information provided is for general guidance and reference purposes only and it is not intended to serve as, nor can it be relied upon, as legal advice to address any specific situation. Those with specific questions are strongly encouraged to contact an immigration attorney.

*About the author

Born in Manila, Licelle Cobrador has over 10 years of experience in immigration and nationality law. Prior to establishing her own firm, Cobrador & Associates, PLLC, Licelle was an associate at a boutique immigration firm in Manhattan and a leading firm in Manila.

Licelle received her B.A. from the University of the Philippines, Manila (Cum Laude, Top 20 out of 267). After earning her J.D. from Ateneo de Manila University, she was admitted to practice law in the Philippines. She completed her LL.M at Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law on a Dean’s Merit Scholarship and was admitted to practice in New York.

Licelle currently serves as Vice President and Executive Director of the Filipino American Legal Defense and Education Fund/ FALDEF and as Volunteer Attorney at the Migrant Center of New York. She is a past co-chair of the Cardozo Law Masters Alumni Community. She is also a member of the Filipino American Lawyers Association of New York/ FALA New York and the National Filipino American Lawyers Association/ NFALA.

Licelle has been selected as TimeIsNow’s Global Filipino Trailblazer. She is recognized as one of Women Today’s Women on the Front Rank, Cardozo Life Magazine’s Movers & Shakers and Cardozo Law’s Outstanding Alumni and has been published in Delaware Law. Licelle is a frequent national and international speaker on U.S. Immigration Law.

ADS

Visit FOREVER Business Owner Nieva Quezon Burdick for a guided self-care program https://aloe23dragon.flp.com/
https://mrhandynyc.com/
Support OSM! Community Journalism by buying any of Leani Alnica’s work of art and Carla Mayol’s photos, starting at $40. Email marivirmontebon@gmail.com for details.
From mother-daughter authors Theda Freques and Sylvia Hubilla: Pepipacifoofoo and Snippets. Order onlinehttps://www.pepipacifoofoo.com/ https://www.lulu.com/shop/sylvia-hubilla/snippets-small-book-of-random-verses/ebook/product-22931687.html?page=1&pageSize=4
Sep 13, 2021Admin
9-11 Memorial Peace Essay: Peace and Unity Amidst DiversityThe Lion King Returns on Broadway with FilAm Vince Ermita as young Simba

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Admin
8 months ago Art & Culture, Immigration, PoliticsDACA, Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA), Judge Andrew Hanen44
0
GooglePlus
0
Facebook
0
Twitter
0
Delicious
0
Linkedin
0
Pinterest
Forums
  • OSM! has a new look. What do you think?
Categories
  • Main Feature
  • Features
  • Feature Event
  • Diane Fermin Roeder: Bamboo Stilletto
  • Debbie Almocera: Cranial Corner
  • Sylvia Hubilla: Granny Gorgeous
  • Ruth D. Ezra: Kit’s Kitchen
  • Leani M. Auxilio: Le Fou’s Stories
  • Janet Villa: Mothering Heights
  • Arlene Donaire: Lensanity
  • Resto Rendezvous
  • Your ZEN Health
  • OSM! VLog
Email-subscription

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest news and event postings.

Most Viewed Posts
The Baby didn’t Come with a Manual
8 years ago
9,682 views
Vanette’s Secret: Cooking Yummy Dried Fish Without the Smell
6 years ago
9,266 views
Maguayan, brother of sky god Kaptan.
The Visayan Creation Myth
10 years ago
7,056 views
FilAm Lt. Christal Theriot: Newest US Army Apache Pilot
5 years ago
6,892 views
Filipinos Known to Take Care of Their Elderly
7 years ago
5,657 views
Recent Posts
  • NYC Commissioners urge NY State Assembly to include Health Coverage for All in State budget March 28, 2022
  • US East Coast Kakampink ask for clean elections; endorse VP Robredo as true servant leader March 28, 2022
  • Filipinos & Filipino Americans Call For Justice at March 30 Rally March 27, 2022
  • Comm. del Castillo to OSM!:  Thank you for the commitment to spotlighting FilAm contributions March 21, 2022
  • OSM! Online Magazine celebrates 10 years of reportage of FilAm communities March 18, 2022
Archives
2014 © OSM!